When is a “Confidential Informant” Really a Police Agent? Crown Stays Charges After Defence Basi Application
On the day its response was due, the Crown stayed the charges against my client.
My client was charged with four counts of possession of a controlled substance for the purpose of trafficking under s. 5(2) of the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, along with one count of possessing proceeds of crime. The investigation began with tips from two people (human sources) the police called confidential informants. We applied to the Alberta Court of Justice in Calgary for a “Basi hearing” to test that label: were these people truly confidential informants (“CIs”), or were they acting as police agents?
The difference matters. If a source is a confidential informant, the law protects their identity almost absolutely. If a source is an agent, the defence is entitled to know what police asked them to do and what they did. On the deadline for its written response to our application, the Crown advised that it was staying the charges.
How the case began
Police obtained a series of warrants, including tracking and transmission data warrants, on the strength of sworn Informations to Obtain (“ITOs”). The grounds rested heavily on two tips about a “dial-a-dope” phone line: Tip #1 was from an RCMP source (the “RCMP Source”) and Tip #2 was from a Calgary Police Service (CPS) source (the “CPS Source”). Tip #1 was generic, noting a phone number being used for drug trafficking with little other detail. Tip #2 included the same basic information as Tip #1 but also had much more information and detail.
The ITOs raised many questions on their face:
- Are the RCMP Source and the CPS Source the same person? The ITOs attested to the existence of two different sources but made no mention of steps taken to confirm the RCMP Source and the CPS Source were two different people. While there was an RCMP CI tracking number associated with Tip #1 and a CPS CI tracking number associated with Tip #2, this could just as easily be explained by someone previously providing information to both police agencies.
- RCMP sent Tip #1 to CPS. The RCMP sent Tip #1 to CPS for the purpose of CPS investigating. Given that Tip #1 had been sent to CPS and the subsequent Tip #2 contained a greater amount of detail, the natural inference is that after CPS received Tip #1, CPS gave the phone number from Tip #1 to the CPS Source along with an “information wish list” and asked them to call the phone number.
- The detail was a buyer's detail. One source was said to know how the line operated day to day, including how it screened new customers. The affiant explained that the screening exists to weed out undercover police. A person who knows that protocol is often a person who tried to buy.
- The source had been “used” before. Police described the CPS Source as having been used in past drug investigations. The ITOs did not say the source’s information had been used before, but that the source had been used before. Use of the person suggests they had been operationally deployed and given tasks to complete.
- The dates did not line up. The ITOs gave inconsistent accounts of when police received the information.
- The official summaries were filtered. The ITOs acknowledged that handlers sometimes “generalize” what a source says and that the information was further vetted.
- Insufficient explanation of claimed informant status. The recitation that the human sources were existing CIs says nothing about whether the sources were CIs on this particular file. A source does not become a CI and automatically maintain CI status indefinitely for all subsequent files. Rather, it is a file-by-file, action-by-action assessment as to their true status.
We asked for the source handler notes, expressly agreeing that every identifying detail could be redacted. That request was refused.
Informant or agent: why the label matters
Informer privilege is one of the strongest protections in Canadian law. Once it exists, it is near-absolute and the court does no balancing: Named Person v. Vancouver Sun, 2007 SCC 43; R. v. Barros, 2011 SCC 51. But it only applies once the court is satisfied, on a balance of probabilities, that the person really is a confidential informant: R. v. Basi, 2009 SCC 52 at para. 39.
The Supreme Court has been clear that not everyone who gives information to police becomes a confidential informant, and that the defence can always challenge a claim of informer status: Barros at paras. 31–32.
The line between the two is well settled. An informant simply passes information to police. An agent acts on police direction and goes “into the field” to take part in the investigation: R. v. G.B., [2000] O.J. No. 2963 (C.A.) at para. 10. An agent's identity and role are disclosable. And the decision is the court’s, not the police’s or the Crown’s. What counts is the true substance of the relationship, not police terminology: R. v. Lising, 2010 BCCA 390 at paras. 40, 58.
This is not a technicality. If a source was a police agent, three things follow:
- Entrapment may be in play. In dial-a-dope cases, police need reasonable suspicion about the phone number itself or person before offering whoever answers a chance to sell drugs: R. v. Ahmad, 2020 SCC 11.
- The warrants may be vulnerable. An ITO that presents one tip as two, or a police-directed purchase as an outside tip, may not support the warrants once corrected: R. v. Garofoli, [1990] 2 S.C.R. 1421; R. v. Araujo, 2000 SCC 65.
- The defence gets disclosure. Records of what police asked the source to do become ordinary disclosure under R. v. Stinchcombe, [1991] 3 S.C.R. 326.
Important Note: There is a voluminous body of case law suggesting information regarding CIs can only be disclosed where innocence is at stake. However, that general rule only applies after a human source has been determined to be a CI as opposed to a police agent.
What a Basi application is, and what we asked for
A Basi application asks the court to decide whether informer privilege actually exists. Because the answer could expose a real informant, the hearing is held in camera, with only the Crown and the source handler present. The accused and defence counsel are excluded.
That exclusion is not the end of the defence’s role. In Basi, the Supreme Court directed trial judges to take all reasonable steps to let defence counsel make meaningful submissions about what happens in their absence: Basi at paras. 55–57. Those steps include defence-proposed questions put by the judge, a redacted summary of the evidence and, in difficult cases, an amicus curiae. Ontario courts have followed that approach, with the judge conducting a vigorous examination of the handler from a defence question list: R. v. Sandhu, 2020 ONCA 479.
Our application asked the Court to:
- hold a first-stage in camera hearing to decide whether privilege attached to each source;
- order the police to produce, under seal for the Justice, the handler notes, debrief reports, tasking records and payment records;
- require each source’s handler to testify;
- put 150 defence-proposed questions to the witnesses, and provide the defence with a judicial summary; and
- appoint an amicus to test the claim, since no one at the hearing would be there to argue the other side.
We were explicit that we did not want any source’s name, address, or description. What we wanted was the conduct: whether police gave a source the phone number, asked them to call it, or asked them to buy. The privilege protects identity and nothing more: R. v. Leipert, [1997] 1 S.C.R. 281. The answer to a confidentiality concern is redaction, not refusal.
The result: the Crown stayed the charges
The hearing never took place. On the deadline for filing its response, the Crown entered a stay of proceedings.
A stay under s. 579 of the Criminal Code halts the prosecution. It is not an acquittal, and it is not a finding by the court. Theoretically, the Crown may recommence the proceedings within one year. If it does not, the proceedings are deemed never to have been commenced. In the case of my client, the Jordan deadline has now passed, so the proceedings could not be successfully recommenced.
The Crown is not required to explain a stay, and we do not speculate about its reasons here. What can be said is that the law puts the Crown to a choice in cases like this. When the defence shows a real basis to question whether a source was an agent, the Crown must prove informer status to the court's satisfaction or face disclosure of what the source did. A label alone does not keep the file closed.
What this means if you are facing charges built on a confidential source
- The label in the warrant is not the last word. Whether someone is an informant or an agent is for the judge to decide, based on what the source actually did.
- The ITO itself can supply the foundation. The defence does not need inside knowledge to bring a Basi application. The threshold is “some basis” in the record, and here every point we relied on came from the police's own sworn document: R. v. Sandhu, [2016] O.J. No. 3036 (S.C.J.), aff'd 2020 ONCA 479.
- Ask for the handler notes early. A refusal to disclose is the start of the analysis, not the end. Offering to accept full redaction of identifying details puts the focus where it belongs, on police conduct.
If you or someone you know has been charged in a case built on a confidential informant, contact Hoare Claxton Criminal Defence in Calgary at (403) 262-7722.
Every case turns on its own facts. This post is general information, not legal advice, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in any other case.




