SafeRoads Alberta Cancels Roadside Sanction Where Police Recording Was Not Disclosed
On November 13, 2026, a SafeRoads Alberta adjudicator cancelled an Immediate Roadside Sanction (IRS: Fail) issued to a Hoare Claxton client for allegedly refusing a roadside breath demand. The adjudicator cancelled the Notice of Administrative Penalty on one ground: police had not disclosed a video recording of the roadside interaction, as the SafeRoads Alberta Regulation now requires.
The decision is an early example of the 2026 amendments in action. Those amendments made police audio-visual recordings a required part of SafeRoads disclosure. It also shows that drivers can rely on their own sworn evidence that a recording was made, even when the police file says nothing about it.
Background
In October 2026, a civilian Range Patrol officer stopped our client on the Cold Lake Air Weapons Range. Range Patrol called the Military Police. Our client was held at the roadside for about two hours while an approved screening device was brought to the scene.
When the Military Police arrived, they demanded a roadside breath sample. Our client declined. A Military Police officer then issued a Notice of Administrative Penalty (NAP) under section 88.1(1)(e) of the Traffic Safety Act for failing or refusing to comply with a demand. An IRS: Fail carries a licence suspension, vehicle seizure and a fine.
During our client's arrest on an unrelated matter, a Range Patrol officer recorded the interaction on a cell phone. The Director of SafeRoads did not include a recording in the review materials, and the police report did not say whether one existed.
On review, we raised several grounds. These included the arguments that the demand did not meet the Criminal Code's immediacy requirement and that the Director's records were incomplete.
The disclosure rule
A driver who receives a NAP can apply for a review by a SafeRoads adjudicator. The adjudicator can cancel the NAP if the Director did not provide the records the law requires (SafeRoads Alberta Regulation, s. 4, and Provincial Administrative Penalties Act, s. 12).
The disclosure rules for police video have changed over time. In 2023, the Court of King's Bench held that fairness required disclosure of audio and video recordings (Smit v Alberta (Director of SafeRoads), 2023 ABKB 435). An August 2023 amendment then said the Director did not have to provide them.
The 2026 amendments (AR 52/2026) reversed that position:
- Section 2(1)(g.1) now requires the Director to provide any audio-visual record made by an officer in the course of issuing a NAP, or a transcript of it.
- Section 2.01 defines that period as running from the officer's first interaction with the driver until the NAP is issued.
- Section 2(3) still says the Director does not have to find out whether a record exists, or confirm to the driver whether one does.
The decision
The adjudicator cancelled the NAP because the Director had not shown that the video-disclosure requirement was met. The adjudicator's reasons focused on four points:
- Recordings are required records. Sections 2(1)(g.1) and 2(2) "are clear that an audio-visual recording made by an officer in the course of issuing a NAP, or a transcript created from that recording, must be provided" (para 9).
- Silence alone does not prove a recording exists. Because of section 2(3), "the absence of a record from the materials provided does not, on its own, establish that the record exists and was withheld" (para 10).
- But the record here pointed the other way. The SafeRoads portal "contains a specific mechanism for identifying circumstances where no audio-visual disclosure exists, and that mechanism was not used." Although the Director need not confirm whether a record exists, "the Director remains required to provide any records contemplated by Section 2(1)(g.1)." The adjudicator also relied on our client's sworn evidence that a video was taken. The officer's report did not say whether audio or video was available (para 11).
- The ground was established. The required record "was not provided in accordance with Section 2(1)(g.1)," so the NAP was cancelled under section 4(i)(ii) of the Regulation (paras 12–13, 15).
That finding decided the review, so the adjudicator did not address the other grounds we raised (para 14). As a result, our client's licence suspension ends and the vehicle can be released from the seizure lot.
Why it matters
Police body cameras, in-car cameras and phone recordings are now routine in roadside investigations. Under the 2026 rules, if any of those recordings were made while the NAP was being issued, the driver is entitled to them. Three aspects of the decision are worth highlighting:
- The driver's own evidence counts. A sworn statement that a recording was made can establish the ground, even when the police file is silent.
- The portal matters. If police have not used the portal to indicate that no audio-visual disclosure exists, an adjudicator may infer that the disclosure obligation was not met.
- The recording does not have to come from a police body camera. In this case, a Range Patrol officer filmed on a phone, and that was enough on these facts.
Each review turns on its own facts, and one adjudicator's decision does not bind another. Anyone who has received a NAP should review the disclosure carefully, including any gaps.
Received a Notice of Administrative Penalty?
The deadline to apply for a review is only 7 days from the date the NAP was issued. Written submissions and evidence must be filed before the hearing. If you have received an Immediate Roadside Sanction in Alberta, contact Hoare Claxton as soon as possible to discuss your options.
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.




